Casric Stars defeat Orlando Pirates by 5-4 in Nedbank Cup

Casric Stars defeat Orlando Pirates by 5-4 in penalities in Nedbankcup following a grueling 120 minutes of football that left the Soweto giants stunned at the Orlando Stadium. On Saturday, 21 February 2026, the Motsepe Foundation Championship side defied all odds to dump the defending champions out of the competition. The result has sent shockwaves through South African football, as the Buccaneers’ hopes of a domestic cup treble were extinguished in a tense shootout.

Casric Stars Nedbank Cup Upset: David Slays Goliath

The Casric Stars Nedbank Cup upset will go down as one of the most significant results in the tournament’s history. Entering the match as heavy favorites, Orlando Pirates were expected to comfortably secure their place in a fifth successive quarter-final. Instead, they met a disciplined and resolute Casric Stars side from Mpumalanga that refused to be intimidated by the bright lights of Soweto.

Abdeslam Ouaddou made four changes to the Pirates side that lost to Mamelodi Sundowns midweek, including handing a start to skipper Nkosinathi Sibisi and new signing Mpho Chabatsane. However, the Soweto giants exit was foreshadowed early on as Pirates struggled to find their rhythm, looking sluggish and mentally fatigued against the lower-tier outfit.

Tshigwana Mthombeni Saves Keep Pirates at Bay

The hero of the night was undoubtedly the Casric Stars shot-stopper. The Tshigwana Mthombeni saves were the bedrock of this victory. In the 23rd minute, he produced a world-class fingertip save to deny Relebohile Mofokeng’s dipping effort.

Throughout the 90 minutes and extra time, Mthombeni was a wall:

• 58th Minute: Denied Mofokeng’s goal-bound free kick.

• 70th Minute: Kept out Deon Hotto after a slick interchange with Tshepang Moremi.

• 105th Minute: Produced a reflex save from close range to deny substitute Kamogelo Sebelebele.

Even when Mthombeni was beaten, the woodwork came to his rescue, as Moremi’s stoppage-time effort rattled the upright. This Motsepe Foundation Championship shock was built on that stubborn defensive display, pushing the game to the dreaded penalty shootout.

Nedbank Cup 2026: Quarter-Final Qualified Teams

As of 21 February 2026

Note: The Nedbank Cup is a knockout competition; therefore, there are no “standings” in a traditional league table format. The above teams have progressed to the Last 8.

Orlando Pirates Penalty Defeat: A Disaster from the Spot

The Orlando Pirates penalty defeat was a catastrophic collapse for the home side. After the match ended 0-0 in 120 minutes, the pressure shifted to the spot. While Casric Stars remained clinical, converting their chances with composure, the Pirates’ experienced defenders faltered.

Skipper Nkosinathi Sibisi, Nkosikhona Ndaba, and Mpho Chabatsane all missed their spot-kicks. The psychological edge firmly belonged to the visitors, who celebrated wildly as the final kick hit the back of the net to make it 5-4. Casric Stars defeat Orlando Pirates by 5-4 in penalities in Nedbankcup, leaving the “Sea Robbers” to reflect on a season where their dominance is suddenly being questioned.

Analysis: What Next for the Buccaneers?

The Soweto giants exit comes at a terrible time for coach Abdeslam Ouaddou. Having lost their lead at the top of the Betway Premiership to just three points after the Sundowns defeat, Pirates now face a crisis of confidence. They must lift themselves for the Soweto Derby against Kaizer Chiefs at FNB Stadium this coming Saturday.

Failure to win the Derby would result in a third successive defeat in all competitions and could see them lose their number one spot on the league log. The lack of clinical finishing—highlighted by Tshepang Moremi wasting two easy chances—is an area that needs immediate attention.

YOU MAY LIKE:

Sundowns Edge Pirates 2-1 in Tense Premiership Clash

Motsepe Foundation Championship Shock

This victory reinforces the “magic of the cup.” Casric Stars followed in the footsteps of TS Galaxy, who earlier on Saturday shocked Mamelodi Sundowns in KwaMhlanga. With three KwaZulu-Natal sides already in the hat, the quarter-finals are shaping up to be one of the most unpredictable in recent years.

The fact that Casric Stars defeat Orlando Pirates by 5-4 in penalities in Nedbankcup proves that the gap between the Premiership and the National First Division is narrowing. For Casric Stars, the dream continues; for Orlando Pirates, the autopsy of a failed cup defense begins.

Mainstream Media References

• Sowetan Live: Casric Stars stun Pirates in Nedbank Cup penalty shootout

• KickOff: Bucs dumped out! Casric Stars claim massive Nedbank Cup scalp

Kindly consider to support eKayNews, Buy Us a Coffee & Keep the News Flowing!

Love what we do? You can now support eKayNews directly! Your contributions empower us to deliver the breaking news, sports, and local updates you trust.

Ways to Support:

• Subscribe: Choose any amount (cancel anytime).

• Virtual Coffee: A quick, once-off donation to say thanks.

Note: Payments are 100% secure via PayFast. We never see your banking details.

To our amazing readers: Your support fills us with gratitude. You are the reason we can keep doing this every day. Thank you for being a vital part of the eKayNews family!

We’re feeling the love at eKayNews!

 Facebook: [eKayNews on Facebook]  X (Twitter): [eKayNews on X]  WhatsApp: [Follow the eKayNews WhatsApp Channel] Join our inner circle for real-time news alerts!

📢 Advertising Packages on www.eKayNews.co.za   

Package 1. Link Booster: We add 7 links to 7 articles over 7 days – R2,500 

Package 2. Permanent Feature: Sponsored Blog Article (hosted permanently) – R4,000 

Package 3. Prime Visibility: Home Page Banner Ad (30 days) – R5,000 

Book now: Email info@ekaynews.co.za or WhatsApp us on +27710961185