White South African Who Came To U.S. After Trump Invite Has Been Detained For Months
White South African Who Came To U.S. After Trump Invite Has Been Detained For Months, marking a stark contradiction in the current administration’s immigration narrative. An Afrikaner who came to the U.S. after President Donald Trump claimed the country would be a safe haven for people like him has been held in federal detention for months since his arrival. Benjamin Schoonwinkel arrived in the United States in September 2025, buoyed by the high-profile Donald Trump South Africa policy that promised priority resettlement for the white minority.1 However, the reality he found at the border was far from the red-carpet welcome he anticipated.
The Arrest of Benjamin Schoonwinkel at Atlanta International
Benjamin Schoonwinkel came to the U.S. in September, believing he would be protected after Trump’s many statements to that effect. But on arriving at an Atlanta airport, he was detained and handcuffed by the U.S. border agents whom Schoonwinkel told he was seeking asylum. Under current U.S. law, claiming asylum at a port of entry—even as a white South African refugee—triggers mandatory detention protocols while the government investigates the validity of the claim.
The South African man was transferred to a federal detention facility within two days and has remained there ever since. After leaving behind a life of relative comfort on the word of Trump, he now sleeps on a metal bunk bed. “I never expected this to happen,” Schoonwinkel said in a video interview with The New York Times this month. “I expected a little bit of red tape, not a cell.”
Life Inside the Stewart Detention Center
The Stewart Detention Center in Lumpkin, Georgia, where Schoonwinkel is held, has about 2,000 other occupants.2 Most of these individuals were taken there as a result of Trump’s broader immigration crackdown. Schoonwinkel says the fact that he is white has perplexed his fellow detainees, most of whom are of Latin American descent. “They all ask me, ‘What are you doing here?’” he said, noting the irony of being a white South African refugee caught in a system designed for mass removals.
Schoonwinkel’s race also stunned his lawyer, Marty Rosenbluth, who, upon taking the case, “assumed he was Black.”
“Why else would he be in ICE custody?” said Rosenbluth. “It never crossed my mind he could be Afrikaner. I thought, how could this be happening?”
Detainee Demographics and Wait Times
According to recent 2025 detention reports, the average length of stay at Stewart has surged as the system becomes clogged with new priority cases.
| Metric | Stewart Detention Center (Dec 2025) |
| Total Population | ~1,928 |
| Average Stay | 51 Days |
| Non-Criminal Detainees | 67% |
| Key Demographics | 82% Latin American, 12% African, 6% Other |
The Contradictions of the Donald Trump South Africa Policy
Rosenbluth said he knew of Trump’s open-door policy toward Afrikaners. The president has consistently claimed that white Afrikaners are victims of “genocide” and are having their land seized by the government, despite facts to the contrary.3 In February 2025, the Donald Trump South Africa policy took a drastic turn when the President ordered that all foreign assistance to South Africa be halted. He promoted the “resettlement of Afrikaner refugees escaping government-sponsored race-based discrimination” as a primary humanitarian goal for the 2026 fiscal year.4
Schoonwinkel’s case directly mirrors the president’s words. His asylum application has notarized proof of an attack on his person and looting of his property in what he says was a racially motivated attack last year. “This is the most winnable asylum case I have ever had,” Rosenbluth said. “All I have to do is present all of Trump’s rhetoric, and everything his administration has been saying, about South Africa.”
The Disconnect Between Rhetoric and Enforcement
It was these actions that prompted a friend of Schoonwinkel, Rick Taylor, to encourage him to come to the U.S. “When I saw President Trump brought some Afrikaners to the U.S., I contacted Ben,” said Taylor. “I said, ‘I think this is a good time for you to come here.’”
But despite Trump’s promises, the Afrikaner asylum seeker has remained in custody for months. Rosenbluth claims he has received no response to his emails to Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). He was eventually informed that upon claiming asylum, Schoonwinkel’s tourist visa was revoked, placing him in the same legal category as any other undocumented arrival.
Homeland Security spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin echoed this in her statement to The Times: “Anyone who claims asylum at a port of entry is subject to mandatory detention while the government investigates their claims. If their claims are found to be valid, they will be granted relief. If they are found to not be valid, they are swiftly removed.” This statement highlights that even for a white South African refugee, the legal process remains rigid.
YOU MAY LIKE:
US demands accountability after SA arrests Kenyans processing Afrikaner ‘refugees’
Conclusion: A Landmark Hearing in 2026
The case of the White South African Who Came To U.S. After Trump Invite Has Been Detained For Months is set for a pivotal hearing next month. This legal battle will determine if the Donald Trump South Africa policy carries actual weight in the courtroom or if it was merely political theater. For Benjamin Schoonwinkel, the wait continues behind the wire of the Stewart Detention Center.
Mainstream Media References
-
The New York Times
-
Title: The Afrikaner Who Believed Trump’s Promise and Ended Up in Jail
-
Link: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/12/28/world/africa/south-africa-afrikaner-refugee-detention.html
-
-
Reuters
-
Title: White South African asylum seekers face detention despite Trump priority
-
Link: https://www.reuters.com/world/us/white-south-african-detained-georgia-asylum-2025-12-28/
-
Kindly consider to support eKayNews, Buy Us a Coffee & Keep the News Flowing!
Love what we do? You can now support eKayNews directly! Your contributions empower us to deliver the breaking news, sports, and local updates you trust.
Ways to Support:
-
Subscribe: Choose any amount (cancel anytime).
-
Virtual Coffee: A quick, once-off donation to say thanks.
Note: Payments are 100% secure via PayFast. We never see your banking details.
To our amazing readers: Your support fills us with gratitude. You are the reason we can keep doing this every day. Thank you for being a vital part of the eKayNews family!
We’re feeling the love at eKayNews!
A massive thank you to our community for your incredible support. You are the reason we keep digging for the truth and sharing the stories that matter. Stay ahead of the curve by following us across all our platforms:
Facebook: [eKayNews on Facebook] X (Twitter): [eKayNews on X] WhatsApp: [Follow the eKayNews WhatsApp Channel] Join our inner circle for real-time news alerts!
📢 Advertising Packages on www.eKayNews.co.za
Package 1. Link Booster: We add 7 links to 7 articles over 7 days – R2,500
Package 2. Permanent Feature: Sponsored Blog Article (hosted permanently) – R4,000
Package 3. Prime Visibility: Home Page Banner Ad (30 days) – R5,000
Book now: Email info@ekaynews.co.za or WhatsApp us on +27710961185
